open topic, for anything cycling related.
The delamination where the carbon starts to unbond is normal when there is continued pressure or stress after the fracture, though would also like to know about the indent. Was it there originally or perhaps happened afterwards (eg. by LBS ir yourself) in probing the extent of the damage. I am wondering if this is an impact that was the catalyst for the fracture. It is an unusual place and I think a stone would be too little though if a stick got caught in the spokes and was spun up and around hitting the frame, that is a possible freak scenario.
On the smart phone so only see the pictures in small, could be way off the mark.
Has anyone here had Cannondale replace a frame under warranty? Or know of friends who've been done right by?
My mate with the Rize 140 as noted above, but they wanted to give him a frame that didn't match the colour of the rest of his running gear.
He had to join the dots for them himself so as to get the right frame colour. They weren't going to swap the running gear to match, that was going to be his tough luck.
Contrast this to how Paul Rowney who distributes Yeti in Oz treats his customers, and Giant. Yes, they break sometimes too, but the turnaround is swift and the customers are always left with a good impression.
Putting "power through the frame" is one thing - this should be loading the bottom bracket and chainstays rather than the seat stays. The failure of both frames suggest that you size/weight, and possibly your riding style, places a lot of stress on the load bearing and/or stress relieving points at the rear of any bike.
I ride a Cannondale as well so I'm sorry to read of your problems. Mine is an alloy frame, I'm 78 kg and still don't trust carbon frames. You may have been badly advised with these two bikes and I certainly hope you can get a satisfactory resolution, but I would be looking for sturdier options in future. Good luck !
Here's my blog - A bit of fun
"Riding not racing...."
I received information which I can't confirm that 80% of frame warranty replacements are honored by Cannondale Australia.
Hmm, not real flash and I would agree with others that the position it has failed is one which bears a great deal of rider weight - by design.
This apparent lack of warranty assistance from Cannondale - in a number of cases - is worrying to say the least. As one who will likely be looking at a brand new bike when a personal goal has been achieved, I am striking any Cannondale carbon product straight from the list. The only reason I may still look at a CAAD10 is that a mate has one and swears by it!
Good luck with your efforts and if necessary, engage VCAT - you will in all likelihood receive a positive outcome.
Yes... On my 3rd warranty frame. No problems at any time.
BTW they have all been for cosmetic reasons so far... never had a frame crack.
I can not say the same about Trek, Gary Fisher, kona, Marin, Raceline, Cytek etc etc
In November 2012 I discovered a crack in bottom bracket on my hi-mod synapse frame (purchased in UK), low k's, 83kg and not powerful, took it to cannondale dealer in Brisbane, had replacement frame within 1 week under warranty, same as in pic above. Great service, only gripe was no choice of colour and not a fan of the matt black/grey i received. Perhaps the hi-mods arent really made for day to day training
My friend had his supersix frame crack on the chainstay, a stick got caught in the spoke, which ripped off the derailleur which fell into the spoke hitting the chainstay and cracking the frame. After kicking up a fuss cannondale australia replaced the frame under warranty as he argued the derailleur falling off caused the damage and not the stick.
Possibly worth noting that it is the responsibility of your LBS to replace a faulty frame. You bought it from them so they have responsibilities under fair trading.
If they want to take it up with Cannondale then that's up to them - but it isn't your problem.
Excellent result - and I must say (as a recent CAAD10 purchaser myself) that you will love the thing - mine flies -even with a boat anchor of a rider attached!!!
Who is online