Thoglette wrote:spirito wrote:Short reach brakes and fenders is a tight squeeze and at best an unhappy compromise. How about 700c with fenders and medium or long reach brakes? I have a few frames that fall into that category.
I don't disagree - the main driver is that my only modern brakes are short reach (old Daytona). Now I realise that I can get some modern medium reach Tektro or Shimano calipers from
Harris but all of the medium reach frames I've seen have old-style fork/bridge drilling and won't take these calipers.
And I do like the stopping power of modern brakes!
It's not as hard as you might think. I've bought modern medium reach (47-57mm) and long reach (50-65mm) calipers by Tektro and Shimano here in Oz. I like Harris Cyclery a lot but Peter Bundy (who is local to me in Sydney) has been able to source these brakes and stock them so I'm happy to spend coin with him. I like the appearance of the Tektro's (polished silver) but the Shimano's (anodized silver) work slightly better out of the box. All 3 sets of brakes improved massively with a change of better pads (either Kool Stop or Mathauser).
The part about old style fork/bridge drillings not accepting modern allen key recessed brake bolts is very simply solved with a drill. Keep in mind this is permanent so if it's a historic make that you might wish to return with it's original parts it mightn't be advised but there is always a work around. Rivendell sells plastic inserts for $1 that and I'm sure something local could also be found in a hardware store

Anyway, the reason I prompted your insisting on short reach brakes is not that I want to sell you one of my frames but because I have a few fendered bikes and quite simply they're a pain in the ass to set up if clearances are tight. They don't line up right, you have to pinch or cut them down around the bridges, a slight knock or buckle and they rub whilst riding etc etc. Been there and done that.
Let alone the issue of not being able to run anything larger than a 20-23c tyre. and because of clearance issues with short reach brakes there are spots that will have only about a 2 or 3mm gap between fender and tyre. In my opinion this is unsafe. Separately, most fenders offered for narrow tyred bikes are crap .... the parts and hardware are rubbish.
A little longer brake calipers and a touch of extra clearance makes things much easier (it's still tricky to set up) and is much advised. A small solution to fiddling with attaching fenders to brake bolt mounts is Sheldon Brown's fender nuts. $15 and available from Abbotsford cyclery ..
http://abbotsfordcycles.com.au/public/content/view/22/38/ They allow snugging the brake down and attaching the fender bridge mount separately ... worth the $15 in my opinion as I only have two hands and it does get fiddly with fender that attach to brake bolts.
Another thing I like is leather washers ... small tip but it's saves a lot of rattling
http://www.velo-orange.com/lewaformofe.html It's easy to make your own.
And check the following links for fender mounting tips (they may be specifically for aluminium fenders but the principles are same)
http://velo-orange.blogspot.com/2009/03/fender-mounting-instructions.htmlhttp://www.peterwhitecycles.com/berthoudinst.aspI have bikes with both plastic and aluminium fenders. There's pro's and con's with either but I lean more towards the Alu ones: they look great, the hardware is often better designed and longer lasting and they're actually lighter !!! Plastic fenders tend to have heavier hardware, stays and attachments. I'm not a weight weenie but I mention this as it's not commonly noted. As with everything you get what you pay for and for the moment I don't think there is an Oz source for alu fenders and hardware.
Think it out. Buy once and know that having a frame and fork properly designed (with space) to accommodate fenders will make the job a lot easier. A bike with well set up fenders can be a beautiful thing. It's the bike I opt for even when it's not raining but when I'm commuting or just traipsing to the shops ... I've found fenders keep a lot of sand and road grime off your bike. And I get happy when it's wet

... I purposefully ride through puddles like an 8 year old

Everybody should have at least one bike with fenders
Some more reading ..
http://www.peterwhitecycles.com/fenders.asp