Workshop tales, trials and disasters.
Maintenance tips, techniques and myths.
Technical discussion, description and outright lies
24 posts • Page 1 of 1
I'am sick and tired of damaging my boot door using a cheap bike stand.
Given that I know own decent Road Bikes, would like to purchase a roof mount.
The car is VE Berlina, not really sure what is required.
What do I need to get, also what model/brand is good and all doesn't cost an arm and leg.
Also would I be able to install it myself or do I need a mechanic.
Lastly where to buy all the requirements from.
Thanks guys, you've been always helpful with such requests.
You are looking at about $329 for Thule roof rack and about $219 ea for Thule ProRide 591 bike racks. You often see the bike racks second-hand on eBay or Gumtree but be wary buying a second-hand roof rack unless it specifically came off the same model car as yours because the foot pack will most likely be different and by the time you buy the correct foot pack the price could well blow out to the same cost as a new roof rack, which obviously defeats the purpose of buying used in the first place.
Sorry - Just a simple question... There's many reasons not to go roof... Here's a few I thought up quickly:
1) the hassle of putting bikes on roof
2) less secure
3) less protected - more risk of stone damage unless u go to the bother of putting bike bras on
4) takes much longer to put the bikes on & off
5) harder to secure them adequately against theft
6) more wind resistance - poorer fuel economy
9) hassle taking off front wheel then having to store them in the boot, taking up valuable boot space
10) look stupid (ok I was clutching at straws for a 10th!)
EDIT: looking at Ross's post about how about expense as no. 10! YIKES!!
However, I'm sure there are 10 good reasons against a hitch mounted carrier too...
Then u could always just refer to the picture above of 3 mangled bikes, which is the main reason I wouldn't put mine on the roof... As I'm stupid enough to forget they are up there and to destroy them like that poor fella...
With a rear hitch carrier you can still get stones and dirt flicking up from the road, obviously not badly if you are driving on sealed roads but definitely on unsealed roads.
If a car runs up your ar$e then your bike(s) are toast.
More rear overhang, car may not fit in garage with bike rack on and public car parks could be a problem too.
Theft is just as much of a (non) problem with rear mount. Both racks have locks available. Supplement with own bike lock if you want. Nothing is thief proof. Even if you put the bike inside the car someone can break a window or force a lock and steal the bike.
Takes 20 seconds to put a bike on a roof rack and probably less to take it down. One strap for each wheel and an arm that clamps around the down tube of the frame.
Roof racks may be a problem if you are short and/or are weak and are trying to lift a heavy MTB onto it but for an average CF road bike it's very easy.
As far as expense, the cheapest Thule towball mounted rear rack is $399, going up to nearly $1000.
I recently bought a 4 bike towball mount channel rack from T7 for $180 which holds 4 bikes, along with the light board for $40 while on special + an accessory plate from PPQ ($66! ripped off being a qld'er, as plates are cheaper in every other state). Sofar, i've put my roadbike, 26" hardtail mtb & son's 20" bike in it and it is as solid as a rock. Nice thing about having a hitch mounted towball is it is so easy to remove from the car when it isn't being used. The rack weighs about 13kg all up and is easy enough to lift on and off the towball and stash inside my car (i have an x-trail mind you) while being solid enough to last a while. Those thule & ISI carriers are nice pieces of kit, but you'll have to weigh up the costs. I'm very happy with t7 rack, and it's getting used every week.
No, it's not an antique Hispano-Suiza Bearcat, it's a Mazda 6, a mass production car like yours - with a tow bar as well as a roof rack.
Just much better quality than my VE Calais!
Get an older Commodore.
/end of thread
I bought a roof mounting system from Seasuckers and it's worked flawlessly for me. I still picture myself on the news/radio having a bike fall off on the motorway each time I use it, but fact is these suck like an angry giant octopus and work as advertised every time.
- extremely quick to mount/dismount both the system and bike
- no cross bars on the car when not needed
- placement of bike can be a lot lower than traditional roof racks. Eg mine is mounted with front fork at the very rear of the roof where it meets the rear window, with the back wheel on the boot lid.
- security is minimal
- that funny gut feeling each time you plod along at 110km/hr with a bike attached to your car using suction cups
FOCUS Cayo Expert
You forgot one good, all the pro teams use them.
24 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: MattyK