Questions about purchasing bicycles and parts
19 posts • Page 1 of 1
Went through the same dilema... Did more research than was actually needed and ended up getting the Garmin. Major reasons for choosing the Garmin: it has better integration to Strava (Bryton is a 2 step process); the Garmin has an option for 1 second sampling, which makes for more accurate MTB tracking; Garmin speed sensor records speed and cadence at the same time (Bryton does one or the other but both at once) and lastly local support for the Garmin seems to be better than for Bryton. YMMV.
FYI, I paid $299 for Garmin 500, speed/cadence sensor and regular HRM from Cecil Walker (Aus stock and warrantee).
They currently have this bundle for $295.
I'm looking to get one next week (hopefully)
2012 Felt F75 | 105 | ProLite Braccianos | GP4000S
The 500 doesn't have mapping or colour.
Its equivalent would be the Rider 35.
Not sure what you mean by this, Nick ... what is my 35 doing when it shows me my speed, heart rate and cadence?
I was referring to the small speed/cadence sensor unit, not the main GPS unit. The Garmin speed/cadence sensor will record both cadence and (traditional) speed/distance using the wheel magnet, in addition to recording lat/lng using the GPS. So you effectively get two sets of speed/distance data. The Bryton speed/cadence sensor has a small switch, which you have to choose between speed or cadence. So it will only record one or the other at any one time. If used on a road bike, then you don't miss much choosing cadence, as the GPS is accurate enough. But on MTB bike you get much more accurate distance data if using the speed sensor setting. E.g. on a known 25km trail I ride, my GPS only unit shows I've ridden only about 21km.
I see what you're saying, Nick.
I'm putting a Garmin sensor unit on a bike I'm getting in the next week or so, to use with my existing Bryton - wonder whether it would also display both?
Use Garmin Connect (of which I know Bryton has a similar site) and also Strava.
The Strava part won me over at the time for the Garmin 500 bundle as the Bryton is a two step process as someone mentioned before.
I have used both units and can see why Garmin got a bit dirty over the look and style of the Bryton when they first evolved.
Very happy with the Garmin unit, but it will come down to user preferences this one.
2013 Malvern Star Oppy Di2
Garmin is the established brand, James, with a more mature product.
The Bryton is a cheaper copy, albeit with a better battery life.
I'd say the bryton rider 50 is more aimed at the garmin edge 705/800, I found this, may be of help: http://users.telenet.be/cyberscan/compare.pdf
I'm selling/swapping my Giant Defy Advanced see here
My LBS suggested the Bryton over the Garmin 500 even though it was almost $100 less. They said that they sell the Brytons about 1:3 however about 15% of those who purchased the 500 are usually back in stall with some type of complaint about their purchase. Never had one with the Bryton.
For that reason, I just picked up a Bryton 30 (though firmware says its a 35) just last night. Will have a chance to test it out tomorrow
FOCUS Cayo Expert
For me :- Garmin all the way.
1) I've got other Garmin products which have never let me down.
2) My wife's company get Garmin products for me very cheap lol
Proudly "a hater of academics with helmet cams"
I don't really 'needed' it either but thought it would be nice to have. If your can stretch the budget a bit get the next one up. Always nice to have a better understanding of your body.
I've decided to turn my commute to a training session.
... Why just plotter along when I can understand and maximize my body
Anyway not having any experience with the Garmin units, I found the Bryton to be quite easy even if there is a 2 step process to get the data uploaded. So Bryton if you're on a bit of a budget
FOCUS Cayo Expert
I use a Bryton 35 with Garmin GCS10 dual speed/cadence sensor & Garmin HR monitor... Works fine.
Always looking for new rides & ride partners in SE QLD area
19 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users