Questions about purchasing bicycles and parts
12 posts • Page 1 of 1
My bike fit has pushed my saddle back quite a far way, beyond the range of the 40mm area that for the rails to be clamped.
So I thought I might look at getting a seat post with greater set back, or a seat with longer rails.
I came across the SMP Stratos
Anyone have any experiences, good or bad? I was looking to getting a saddle with a cut out eventually so this may kill two birds with one stone.
There's also the 'Dynamic' that Steve Hogg champions on his very long review:
http://www.stevehoggbikefitting.com/blo ... bout-smps/
I'm 167cm, 65kg, 30 inch waist, or thereabouts.
The manufacturers sizing guide suggests I should be okay with the Stratos (266mm x 131mm)
While Steve talks about the Dynamic, I may well be one of the 'small statured light weights' that Mr Hogg refers to as being suitable for the saddle, or its variant with less padding, the 'evolution.
I currently use a Serfas Road saddle (295mm x 135mm) which was chosen by a bike store guy because it was the cheapest one hanging off the wall. I've not previously been that fussy about saddles, although on a long ride over the weekend I did notice a bit of heat and slight numbness so it would be good to get something better:
https://www.serfas.com/products/view/21 ... s%7Cpage:2
I don't have any specific knowledge of Steve other than he seems well regarded - and he wrote the very long review of the SMP saddles.
I was happy to go with the manufacturers' recommendation - til I saw the post singing the praises of Dynamic.
Hi JV911, what's your dimensions, if you don't mind me asking.
Its curious that Steve and Selle SMP have such a divergent opinion on the suitability of the Composit, Evolution and Stratos. According to SMP those saddles would suit Extra Small, Small to Medium. Whereas Mr Hogg suggests its only for really small guys - not your average.
Different average body shape between Italians and Australians perhaps?
I ride the stratos and my husband the evolution (or the other way around - I ride the one with slightly more padding). Totally love it and the quality is perfect.
The "size" of the saddle is really more about sit bones and widths. As an idea, my husband is m-l jersey size, 34/87 cm waist. He's about 82kg and 170cm. I'm a chick (I'm guessing you got that already) weigh 81kg, 169cm and a l-xl men's jersey depending on cut. I'm certainly not thin. The saddle is fine for me and I am considering the same on all my bikes.
I Highly recommend trying a couple of models. A slight tweak will make this saddle comfy or a torture device so don't be afraid to ask the lbs to fiddle with angles etc. I've also found that I sit back a bit further on it but don't move around as I used to on a "normal" saddle. There will be some getting used to for sure.
Hope this helps - it may not be for you
175cm, 84cm waist and 74kg...need to lose the 2kg i gained in France
one of my mates has the Evolution and he is bigger than me. I tried it briefly but wasn't a huge fan but that could have as much to do with bike set up than the seat itself. My mate has shorter legs than me despite being taller
Thanks Moosterbounce - I think this is telling me that I need to go to the LBS and stick my butt on one of the seats! Given your measurements it sounds like I should be a contender for the Stratos as I'm a little narrower in the waist than your husband. But I spoke briefly to Port Melb Cycles and the difference in Stratos and Dynamic is as much in shape as in the width measurement.
Thanks JV, bah - 2kgs is a smoothie and a (rather large) sandwich! Thanks for the measurements.
These saddles. AMAZING!
So i went down to Port Melbourne cycles to try the saddles they had available. They had loaners available as well, although the models I was interested in were currently on loan. I tried the Stratos (narrow, but with padding) the Lite 105 (Forma shape, with padding) and the Dynamic (Forma Shape, minimal padding).
As soon as I 'sat' down on the stratos it was an absolute revelation. I knew immediately I was going to cycle home with a new saddle, just wasn't sure which one. I ended up choosing the dynamic. The stratos was so narrow that I felt I was sliding around just a little. The dynamic seemed hold me in position a little better, and the minimal padding would be better in the long run I thought.
I've commuted with the saddle with jeans and it has been great. Yesterday I did 90km with the saddle in knicks and it was amazing. No soreness at all. No numbness or burning whatsoever. It seems that the seat is positioned in such a way so that your entire body rests on the saddle via your sit bones. The rest of the seat is hollow and scalloped out where your mooshy man (or woman) bits would typically be compressed and cause discomfort. Its almost like being a camera on top of a camera tripd. You sit on this pedestal that locks in with your bony undercarriage, but leaves the soft bits alone. So all in all, totally worth the (sizeable) investment.
The only qualifications i would make for those who might be interested in trying these seats is that I'm relatively light - and I've recently had an excellent bike fit. So the saddle does, like all saddles I guess, rely on much of your weight being on the pedals and your arms. I imagine that if you aren't optimally fitted, the curious nature of this seat could potentially exacerbate a bad situation.
I was also tempted to buy online initially but glad I went to a store and paid full retail just for the benefit of having a few to try. If I'd gone online, I would've chosen the wrong one.
This saddle has been a game changer for me. Similar to what it felt like riding a modern road bike for the first time after enduring a badly maintained shogun mountain bike for years. I'd highly recommend anyone who has saddle issues to check one out one time.
12 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: MSNbot Media, Shiny Side Up