Nobody wrote:briztoon wrote:nickl wrote:On a commute, wear whatever you want.
But... A Saturday afternoon a few weeks ago I was out climbing a popular road climb (Norton Summit) and I'd have seen 3 or 4 rider in full lycra, but wearing baggy shorts over the top. I think that looks pretty weird.
Noobies who are self conscious. It can take a little while for some people to come to terms with full lycra.
Yeah, maybe I'll get there before I'm old. I didn't have a problem with it 20+ years ago though.
I often compare cycling clothes with swimwear.
If you want to be fast and efficient, wear speedos / knicks. Yes, you look silly. So does everybody else. They're probably not something you would want to be seen in without some very strong context cues to reinforce that you're dressed for a specific sporting purpose.
Don't wear underpants under your speedos / knicks. Ewwww. Uncomfortable. Soggy. Bad.
If you're too self-conscious to get about wearing just a single layer of lycra over your unmentionables, wear some lightweight shorts over the top of your speedos / knicks (or wear shorts with an appropriate built-in liner). You'll lose some of the benefits, but you won't feel like a half-naked weirdo. People who are seriously into the sport will look sideways at you and scoff.
Over time, assuming you stay with the sport, you'll come to realise that there's nothing exceptional about your body that makes it any less lycra-appropriate than plenty of other lycra-clad bodies out there, and in your own time, you'll probably lose the modesty shorts. Something you could never do, except that everybody else has already normalised it. Feels a bit weird and pervy the first time, but feels good to be rid of those silly flappy over-pants.
A few years later, you'll look at other newbies wearing footy shorts over their speedos / knicks, scoff a little, and chuckle that you ever felt the need to cover up like that.
In some circles (MTBers, surfers), the lycra thing isn't really normalised. At least, not outside of competition. Then it becomes a choice whether to follow social convention, or be comfortable and have your peers think you're a bit of a weirdo.
Of course, continuing the analogy, you don't need to wear speedos to swim. If you find yourself at a beach on a hot day wearing street shorts and undies, go ahead and swim. You might not be as fast as some guy in budgie smugglers, but that's hardly the point. It might be a bit clammy and uncomfortable walking around in damp jocks after you get out, but that's the compromise you make. Likewise, riding in casual clothes. Not as comfortable, but easier and more convenient.
tim