open topic, for anything cycling related.
2 cases come to mind Janine Shepherd author of Never Tell Me Never she was hit by a car while out training. A group of guys wanted to rush her to hospital but a witness to the crash stopped them from moving her. As a result she went on to great things in aviation which she never would have from a wheelchair.
2nd is little Sophie Delezio (sp)
She was trapped under a car and suffered horrific injuries.
It comes down to this. If you witness a crash and your not medically trained you do the best you can at the time. Hoping you don't make things worse in doing so
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using Tapatalk 2
A great adventure starts with a single step
Correct! That's the Russian Roulette I talked about earlier. Prevention of accident is the best bet!
Bianchi, Ridley, Montague, GT, Garmin and All things Apple
No, simply pointing out there can be consequences when people react without thinking.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2
I ride, therefore I am.
...real cyclists don't have squeaky chains...
No one suggested there's no consequence. But that's often the dice one rolls and the balance of evils at the time.
Sent from my iThingy...
I ride, therefore I am.
...real cyclists don't have squeaky chains...
You still have not established that this so called point of danger. The road won't open up and swallow the cyclists. The risk of other traffic on the road in such a circumstance is normally non existent. It is normally trivial to ensure that oncoming traffic is aware of the situation and wont present a danger.
Surely we can all make our own choices. Personally I would be happy to be micro-chipped with my full medical history. Odds are if I fall off my bike and I am not air-lifted quickly to a major hospital then I could die. The police/ambos need to know this ASAP. For now the RoadID does the job. Hopefully I never need it but buying it and wearing it is a very small price to pay.
Yes, so many in the community need to be spoon fed on what are danger and what are not. That why it'll always be a dice throw.
A better tactic would be to place some bystanders up the road to warn oncoming traffic and place some stationary vehicles between the patient and danger.
Rushing a potential spinal pt off the road Lebanon style, limbs flailing is probably not the best approach. Better to mitigate the danger without moving the patient, in the absence of the correct equipment.
That clearly can't always be counted on given the lighting, weather, road condition, number of helpers etc etc. It's one of those assessment one has to make on the scene.
"Rushing" is sensationalistic. If the helper lacked clinical first aid skills, do you think they are guaranteed to have the skills to look after the big picture? For those with knowledge, there are ways to move a patient safely. If the spinal injury is already so bad that it can't be moved with care, then even ambos with their neck brace and spinal board will unlikely to completely avoid further injuries. As said, rule 1 is to avoid putting helpers in danger.
That is perhaps so, but they have a much better chance of moving someone with a spinal injury appropriately given the training and equipment than those without.
The first choice is not to move a patient with a spinal injury until those with the training and equipment arrive. Life over limb yes, but it is best avoided until other options are exhausted.
Back on topic ... I always carry my Cycling Australia licence which not only has my name on it, but an emergency contact. Lots of people haven't realised that but in my club we ask people to always ride with that licence. I carry mine in a little plastic wallet that also carries enough $$ to get lunch, coffee or whatever and if I'm going on a long ride, a credit card. I always take the licence with me when cycling because sometimes if I'm racing I have to show it. So it's a standard part of my kit.
Recently one of our club members crashed and didn't have his licence or anything with emergency contact details. Fortunately the club secretary was with us and able to get into the CA membership data base from her smart phone at the accident scene and get contact details . Don't you love technology?
At that accident, he couldn't be moved, was on a blind corner and fortunately there were enough people around to manage traffic rather than try and move him. Not that there was anywhere to move him to as it happens. I think you have to take every situation as you find it and use your best judgement to manage risk.
Assuming we are talking about the same case, that's a different scenario as it's on a community ride with large number of cyclists around. Situation would be very different if it was a solo rider on a busy road. But as already stated, one needs to judge wisely on a per case basis.
Oh, OK. Thanks. I'll go read some other thread then...
This is in danger of becoming a defacto MHL thread.
I carry ID because of several reasons. 1 is it might help in the case of an accident. 2 is that it isn't that hard. Really.
Grenade thrown, time to move on.
In regards to spinal injuries and potential collateral damage, I hope I am never in that situation (giver or receiver), but each person has to judge the situation at the time, and all the armcahir experts who pass judgement after the fact, from an armchair and say "Yeah, but ..." can go get stuffed.
Lest we end up like the recent US example where the nursing home would not administer CPR, as it was not their policy to do so, but to wait for expert trained personnel. That person died. I'd rather be paralysed than dead.
Until then, risde safe and carry ID.
We're not talking CPR, withholding that will leave you dead or with a brain injury.
I was advocating not moving a potential spinal pt unnecessairily. Investigate other options first.
I don't think anyone was advocating withholding first aid, just avoiding pt movement in certain circumstances if possible.
I am not sure i would rather be alive and a quadriplegic. I would rather avoid the injury first.
Because we are all still trying to ID each other.
Some days you are a big, strutting rooster, some days you are a bit chicken and some days you are just a complete cocque. Roger Ramjet: 2009 Giant CRX3 Spockette: 2009 Trek FX 7.3 (WSD, property of Mrs Monsoon) Lady Penelope: 2011 Avanti Cadent 1.0 TdF
Aaaargh! Begone horrible visions!
London Boy 29/12/2011
Because the forum is having a quiet moment.
This has been done before but it has never reached 5 pages.
(If you don't carry an ID, there is something seriously wrong with you)
I can’t believe it . Some of my most popular threads have reached only 3 pages.
Well pines joke corner is doing well
A successful man is one who makes more money than his wife can spend. A successful woman is one who can find such a man.
Speak your mind,Those that mind dont matter, Those that matter dont mind!!
Who is online