Postby brawlo » Mon May 13, 2013 4:06 pm
Get those 180s on Twizzle!
The thing I get from this discussion is that it may or may not work for you. There are 2 ways to establish this, I think. One is to engage with a good experienced coach that can look at you and what you have been doing etc, and make an informed decision based on experience. Not all coaches will be able to do this, and the answer may still be wrong. The other way is to just do it and see if it works. The best way to go about this is to have some structure about it so that you're not barking up the wrong tree with what you do.
You can see from TLL that he has given the training some thought and it doesn't seem that it would work for him.
I started weights training again last winter after nearly 10 years off. I had the intention of continuing weights through the summer track season but didn't end up doing so. Even so, I was on the bike 6 days a week between road and track training/racing. I think that the weights helped me with getting some usable strength into my legs, but it took a good month or 2 before it really translated into the pedals. Moreso, I think that the weights took the place of the strength work on the bike that I wasn't able to do due to the winter daylight hours. From my experience, I know that it's certainly not the magic pill so to speak (probably not the best analogy in cycling these days) but I think that it does help my riding.
Interestingly on another note pointed out before re unnecessary muscle mass, yes there is some. I got a birds eye view to that when I stepped under the squat bar this winter. The bulk of the quads had more than enough strength in them, but there were certain parts of the legs and back that needed to be worked up slowly.
If you're not up to getting a trainer, then I think you should give a structured regime a go and see how it works. You don't really have a lot to lose and you can answer a few questions along the way. You may need to be prepared to sacrifice a season or 2 in playing it out though. Up until a month or so ago, I would have said get onto the track (and I think I did say that to you), but that's at least not an immediate option for you.